Reviewing A Research Paper

Tags: Effective Time Management EssaysArgument Essay TipsEssays On Going Home By Joan DidionEssays About Operations ManagementOxbridge EssaysEssays On Beauty

The responses have been edited for clarity and brevity.

I consider four factors: whether I'm sufficiently knowledgeable about the topic to offer an intelligent assessment, how interesting I find the research topic, whether I’m free of any conflict of interest, and whether I have the time.

Then, right in the Introduction, you can often recognize whether the authors considered the full context of their topic.

After that, I check whether all the experiments and data make sense, paying particular attention to whether the authors carefully designed and performed the experiments and whether they analyzed and interpreted the results in a comprehensible way.

Do the hypotheses follow logically from previous work? To what extent does the Discussion place the findings in a wider context and achieve a balance between interpretation and useful speculation versus tedious waffling? (Then, throughout, if what I am reading is only partly comprehensible, I do not spend a lot of energy trying to make sense of it, but in my review I will relay the ambiguities to the author.) I should also have a good idea of the hypothesis and context within the first few pages, and it matters whether the hypothesis makes sense or is interesting. I do not focus so much on the statistics—a quality journal should have professional statistics review for any accepted manuscript—but I consider all the other logistics of study design where it’s easy to hide a fatal flaw.

Mostly I am concerned with credibility: Could this methodology have answered their question?(In my field, authors are under pressure to broadly sell their work, and it's my job as a reviewer to address the validity of such claims.) Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. I also pay attention to the schemes and figures; if they are well designed and organized, then in most cases the entire paper has also been carefully thought out.First, I read a printed version to get an overall impression. When diving in deeper, first I try to assess whether all the important papers are cited in the references, as that also often correlates with the quality of the manuscript itself.The only other factor I pay attention to is the scientific integrity of the journal.I would not want to review for a journal that does not offer an unbiased review process.Unless it’s for a journal I know well, the first thing I do is check what format the journal prefers the review to be in.Some journals have structured review criteria; others just ask for general and specific comments. I almost never print out papers for review; I prefer to work with the electronic version.I usually consider first the relevance to my own expertise.I will turn down requests if the paper is too far removed from my own research areas, since I may not be able to provide an informed review.I'm more prone to agree to do a review if it involves a system or method in which I have a particular expertise.And I'm not going to take on a paper to review unless I have the time.


Comments Reviewing A Research Paper

  • Custom Research Paper Writing Services Reviews.

    Basically, research papers stand on the same difficulty level as term papers. So why do we have a separate category for custom research paper services and custom term paper services reviews then? Well, it’s because a research paper is about revealing something new, while a term paper is summarizing the whole academic term.…

  • Writing a Literature Review Research Paper A step-by-step.

    Research paper is to develop a new argument, and a research paper will contain a literature review as one of its parts. In a research paper, you use the literature as a foundation and as support.…

  • Format for reviewing an article -

    A literature review is a summary of what research has been completed in a topic area; it should be summarized in your own words. Read the entire article first and then go back and take notes. Jot down notes in your own words. This increases comprehension as well as decreases the likelihood of plagiarism.…

  • How To Write a Good And Interesting Article Review - A.

    How To Write an Article Review – Tips and Explanation What is an article review? An article review is a piece of writing where you summarize and assess another person’s article. It entails a logical evaluation of the central theme of the article, supporting arguments and implications for further research.…

  • Sample Expert Scientific Review Report -

    The first sentence that is, provide references to other groups who do or have done research in this area. The second sentence helpfully explains the motivation for the research to current and potential funding agencies. However, to make the motivation clearer and to differentiate the paper some more…

  • Article Review Examples

    Reviewing an article is not as easy as it sounds it requires a critical mind and doing some extra research. Check out our article review samples to gain a better understanding of how to review articles yourself.…

  • Top 10 Best Essay Writing Services of 2019 Ranked by Students

    Trust My Paper is a superior writing service, which has got a reputation of a reliable company that provides students from all over the world with quality writing services. You should definitely take this service into account if you are new to the online writing companies.…

  • Educational Research Review - Journal - Elsevier

    The Journal of the European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction EARLI Educational Research Review is a international journal aimed at researchers and various agencies interested to review studies in education and instruction at any level. The journal will accept meta-analytic reviews, narrative reviews and best-evidence syntheses. • Research reviews Reviews aimed at comparing research on similar or related topics.…

  • How to Write a Literature Review for an Academic Paper Pen.

    The literature review component of an academic paper compiles key pieces of literature used for research. It doesn't simply list the research materials. The review provides a summary, evaluation and comparison of the materials without adding your own ideas to the mix.…

  • How to review a research paper? - YouTube

    The purpose of peer review is to ensure 1 quality, checking that no mistakes in procedure or logic have been made; 2 that the results presented support th. Skip navigation Sign in…

The Latest from ©