Here are 10 keys from editors of APA journals to guide you: At its core, a manuscript review is made up of three sections: After you have read the manuscript—and before you start writing—scour the journal and pay attention to how the articles are presented.
Here are 10 keys from editors of APA journals to guide you: At its core, a manuscript review is made up of three sections: After you have read the manuscript—and before you start writing—scour the journal and pay attention to how the articles are presented.Take note of the formatting, the order of the sections and the level of detail expected in the articles.Be sure that you have a clear understanding of the journal’s intended audience.Tags: In Favor Of Corporal Punishment EssaysHow To Plan A Business TripMech Unsw ThesisEugene O'Neill DissertationData Communication Research PapersEssay On Nature For Junior Students
On day one, he reads the manuscript through once without making comments or taking notes.
"I sit at my desk, and I don’t have a pen in my hand; I don’t have anything. On day two, he marks up the manuscript with all his comments.
I wrote a paper a few months ago, which I submitted to a journal and is currently under review. Lately I have been thinking about a few things with a colleague and we came up with a small project which uses the results of my paper.
The new paper is already written, and we are planning to submit it to a journal (not the same one).
Some journals keep both the authors and the reviewers anonymous, while others give both parties the option to remain anonymous.
Many journals provide reviewers with criteria for evaluating each section of a manuscript.
"The manuscript might be really good," Sokol-Chang says, "but perhaps not for that particular journal." An example would be if you’re reviewing a very technical manuscript for a broad journal such as , which focuses on major developments across all of psychology.
"In your note to the author, you should feel free to make suggestions about the best place to resubmit the manuscript," Sokol-Chang adds.
While your first thought may be, "I don’t have time for this," reviewing manuscripts can be a great opportunity.
Reviewers get an early view of what’s happening in their fields, better insight into how the review process works and a chance to network, all of which can foster your career, says Rose Sokol-Chang, Ph D, publisher of APA journals.